"The girl in the wheelchair" speaks
http://www.echoingthesound.org/phpbbx/viewtopic.php?p=1557266#1557266
http://www.echoingthesound.org/phpbbx/viewtopic.php?p=1557459#1557459
http://www.echoingthesound.org/phpbbx/viewtopic.php?p=1558533#1558533
http://www.echoingthesound.org/phpbbx/viewtopic.php?p=1558591#1558591
http://www.echoingthesound.org/phpbbx/viewtopic.php?p=1558652#1558652
There has been some mild speculation and assumptions about my attendance at the NIN show in Philly. I am talked about on ETS by people who think they know what the deal was. They don't.
Let me begin by saying that 08.29.08 was my eighth NIN show, not my first. Eighth. My first show was in '96 when he toured with Bowie and you know where I was? Against the fucking rail. Off to the side and I was much smaller then, but I was against the rail. Eight shows in, I know what to expect. I know how it works. Of those 8 shows, I watched 6.5 of them either blocked by tall people too fucking rude to move or from a mile away in the bullshit handicapped sections designated at all the venues.
Two days before the Philly show, I attended the East Rutherford one. I had presale seat tickets that I TRADED for handicapped accessible seating. I TRADED my beautiful foiled presale tickets. The venue staff was MORE than kind to me. I was told to wait inside, not outside in the line with everyone else even though I was willing to. I'm always willing. I'm not some high and mighty ass that thinks they deserve special treatment. In fact, it kind of annoys me. While I was waiting, I happily listened to sound check through the door. I made friends with the venue staff also waiting around. Just before everyone was going to be let in, a bearded man came up to me and asked where I was sitting. I explained how I traded my tickets for something accessible and he told me "You shouldn't have done that. I would have found a better spot for you somewhere." Needless to say, I kicked my ass the rest of the night for doing the swap. Not only did I miss out on having a better seating arrangement, but I also lost out on being able to have pretty presale tickets to add to my collection.
When Philly came I had bought presale GA tickets. Because of what happened in East Rutherford, I was determined to NOT trade in my tickets and just deal with what came about when it was time. When I arrived at the box office the woman gave me a very hard time, saying wheelchairs are not allowed on the floor, that I HAVE to trade my tickets, that there is no elevator down and then refused to give them to me. The fact that she kept calling me "honey" did not help things.
I would like you to momentarily put yourself in my position. Remove the wheelchair fact... if someone was refusing to give YOU what you PAID for and telling YOU that you cannot go where you PAID to go, how would you react? I think most people would go insane. Few people would nod and smile through that. I told the woman, in the nicest way I could muster that I'm aware of the situation, but I PAID for GA tickets so she should give me what I paid for and that I'll deal with where I sit when I get inside. Tickets gotten, and so I wait again. Like East Rutherford, venue staff told me to wait inside and not out in the line with everyone else.
I had no plan. All I knew is that I did not want to trade these foiled tickets again for a piece of paper. I figured I'd get inside, get a wristband, ask around where I should go and end up in the back of the GA floor far from any action. We asked an event staff guy if there was an elevator inside to get down to the floor and he said "Oh yeah, when you go in, just take a right and it's by section 110." The bitch at the box office lied to me.
I was let in first and the wristband woman refused to give me a wristband despite my ticket saying GA on it. A mild argument ensues because, again, they do not want to give me what I PAID for. Again, ask yourself how you would react. Meanwhile, my 14 year old, 5', 100lbs niece WAS able to get a GA wristband even though she herself could be labeled as small and "helpless" in that crowd. No one gave a rats ass about her "safety" or any other small girl's safety. Meanwhile, I have a fucking metal barrier around me to protect me from getting crushed to death.
We go to speak to the event supervisors who simply keep repeating "No wheelchairs are allowed on the floor" and "You have to go to Guest Services". When asked why, they just said it's their "policy". When asked if I could sign a waiver, they refused. When asked if I had a cane and not a wheelchair would I be allowed down there, they shrugged their shoulders. When asked if there was an elevator that would be able to take me down to the floor, they said yes but I wasn't allowed to use it. Let me stress that I was NOT asking to be in the front. I was simply asking to be allowed down there, anywhere. Anyone who has ever been to any show knows that the back of the floor is always, always clear and safe. I have never once in my 30 years and 100+ shows ever seen a GA floor totally packed to the back with people.
Frustrated, we head to Guest Services, which is closed. The more the seconds tick, the more angry I become. They have the means to allow me to be where I PAID to be. I said I would sign anything they wanted me to sign so they would not be responsible if anything should happen. I look around and see the GA line forming inside. No one is being let in yet since sound check is still going on. I have a ballsy thought, "What if we just... go into the elevator and push down instead of up?" We walk around the arena to the elevator, security everywhere, no one stopped us. In the elevator, down is pushed. It opens into an underneath area/tunnel filled with equipment. I pass security on my way through and they do nothing but smile at me. I reach the GA floor where there is a simple movable metal barrier. I can see the stage. Sound check is still happening. Security is wandering, getting ready. I decided to just wait in the tunnel until everyone else starts to come in because it's the right thing to do. Justin Meldal-Johnsen passed me in the tunnel and did a smile/nod while we waited. Security saw me there and never asked me to leave.
People start filing in and I pass through the barrier. I pass security who are simply looking at wristbands. I quickly scan the people against the rail and see a strong looking guy and a tall girl. I ask if I can please squeeze between them since I'm short and they seemed to have no problem with it. It's then that I realize I am DIRECTLY in front of Trent's mic. I quickly recall my experience in Baltimore and how amazing it was, how loving everyone around me was, how they fought for me so I could stay up there in the front. This was way closer than Baltimore and my excitement grew, but I also knew what we were in for. Crowd surfers falling over my head, shoving, pushing, surges, pits close by... but we have done this before, front and center. I also figured that an all NIN crowd would be more respectful than the one in Baltimore who consisted of a bunch of different types of people. I thought it would become a family up there, everyone fighting for the same cause, like it was in Baltimore. Little did I know...
I tried to make friends with the people to my left and right. I told the guy next to me that I was thankful he was there. I talked to the tall girl, who simply called dibs on marrying Trent Reznor. Vic (not my father) was behind me talking up a storm to the guys back there. He also tried talking to the tall girl next to me who said in a snotty way "I wish you luck, man" but what do you want from someone who thinks Trent would marry them.
I feel I should say that I am a NIN fan to the core. 15+ years worth. Mr. Reznor is not my God or my Idol. I respect him far too much to give him silly labels like that. His music has been the soundtrack for half of my life. The ability to be close to him while he sings these songs that are so deeply ingrained in me is profound. I don't want to be close because I think he's sexy or because I think he'll fall in love and marry me. I don't want to touch him, yell things at him, throw shit at him, lick him or any other such nonsense. I do, however, want the connection that you can't get from across an arena.
His intro music came on and my nervousness and excitement was off the chart. He came blasting out ready to kick everyone's ass. The energy was insane. He scanned the front row while he sang. He paused on me. He wasn't looking over my head, to my right or my left... it was me. That one moment of connection, just a moment, is what I waited 15 years for and it finally happened. I teared up with joy and I had all I ever wanted right then. He kept his eyes on me at different periods through the first song. I know many, many fangirls always think the singer is looking at them. I'm aware of how it sounds. But from Mr. Reznor's perspective, there was an odd hole in front of him in the crowd. He would look to see why. He would see a small me right there.
The crowd, though moving, was just fine. I was just fine. I was in my bliss, happily singing along. Things stayed pretty okay until March of the Pigs when the giant shove happened and my knees implanted themselves into the barricade. The force caused me to bend at the waist and I bumped my chin off the barricade. Still, I was okay and not scared. I was, however, wondering what happened to fans who are a family and in it together. Everyone was simply for themselves, aside from a chosen few. The assholes overpowered things though. I've come to learn there was a "1-2-3-PUSH" thing going on and that's what I got directly on my knees. I read many complaints about people in the crowd being disrespectful. Pick-pockets, rude frat guys, guys pulling down girl's shirts.
During the chaos, I looked at Trent to see he was watching me. He sang, he performed but he also watched. He saw a problem and watched me until it was taken care of.
The decision to leave was because I feared the safety of my niece, not myself. I was fine. She took the brunt of the shove. We signaled and before I could even grab my own control box to move out of there, I was through the crowd.
I read that someone said I looked "scared shitless" but I don't know when that could have been. Bewildered is what I think I was. Perhaps that person looked at me in the moment my knees got crushed, I don't know. Scared is not what I was. Happy, excited, in the moment... but not scared. I knew what I was getting into. It wasn't anybody's idea except my own.
Maybe it was stupid. That's up for debate. But you see, I am a firm believer in the universe. I believe things line up for a reason and when I see the opportunity to follow that flow, I do it. If there's one thing I have always had, it's balls. It's a gutsy, ballsy move to go against the grain and that's exactly what I did. I didn't roll over and submit when someone told me no. I demanded the same respect everyone else has and I did it with a smile. I thought other people would see that determination in me the evening of the show and that I deserved to be up there just like everyone else. Little did I know, I was seen as stupid and helpless, in the way and a problem. People thought it was Vic's call, thinking that I don't have a mind of my own. Not one person thought, "Wow that was stupid, but SHIT does that girl have balls!" No one.
After leaving the floor, I watched the rest of the show from the designated shit handicapped seats. This was, by far, the most emotional show I've been to. I connected, deeply. I would not, for any reason whatsoever, go back and change my actions. To those who were so very, VERY inconvienced because I was not where I belonged... suck my dick.
See you all in VA!
Comments
I was in the pit too at the Philly show and your post has gotten me so steamed I joined this friggen web site.
First, your logic is flawed. You bought your ticket under false pretenses. They would NEVER had sold you the ticket in person - PERIOD.
I understand your passion for the band and desire to get as close as possible, but the wheel chair is not only a danger for you - it's a danger for us. It creates a hole that a crowd surfer could fall into. It's a hard imoveable object that any of us could have been pushed into. What about the rest of us?
If a person 500 lbs buys one (1) coach airplane ticket on-line, then that person may be surprised to find out when they show up at the airport to claim their seat, that if they can't fit into the one seat, then federal law requires the passenger to buy two (2) tickets.
You bought your ticket under false pretences and then demanded treatment as if you did nothing wrong.
I think it's great you love the band, and I'm sorry for your affliction - but let's call a spade a spade - it wasn't stupidity on your part to demand floor access - it was selfishness, which you accomplished through lying.
I did NOT buy my ticket under false pretenses. I bought them through the presale and "handicapped" was not an option. Seats and GA is all. Seats are not accessible for me but GA is.
What about the danger a crowd surfer causes for the people under him? I've been at shows where crowd surfers fall and injure the people under them all the time and they themselves get up just fine. They run the risk of falling into a hole no matter what. Short people exist everywhere.
Oh, you mean like the rail that everyone gets crushed against? No one cares about getting pushed into that.
Comparing the situation to an overweight person who has to buy two airline tickets is just ridiculous. My ticket costs the same as everyone elses no matter where I sit. I don't need an extra seat. In fact, I need no seat at all.
Selfishness? Does the selfishness lie in the person who has the same rights as everyone else, or the person who thinks that right shouldn't be allowed.
If they really felt they were liable, wouldn't someone have said..."Yikes, it could hit the net that someone in a wheelchair was in the mosh pit...don't let her in there."
Regardless of what happened, I'm glad to hear you had a great time, and hope that any other GA related events don't end up as smooshy (for want of a better word, that's what it feels like in there sometimes) as the one you wrote about. I'm pretty sure that Reznor noticed you out there, which is always a cool thing at a concert. :)
So a few days ago I read about "the girl in the wheelchair" on ETS and was immediately intrigued. I got this link from there and I read the whole story and I had to comment. I checked your profile, and, funny enough, I am also SMA type 2, so needless to say I am in a wheelchair.
Recently I saw NIN at the Palace of Auburn Hills, and I can atest to how shitty the handicapped seating is. There were about 15-20 people behind me, and I honestly think they were the only ones in the entire place who had shittier seats than me. I originally had presale tickets, and knew Id need to have them switched, so I called about 2 weeks after buying them. Having never been to the Palace I was hoping that they would be in a somewhat decent section, so I was a little disappointed when I looked up where the handicapped section is on the venue website and saw that I was all the way in the back.
I thought about being on the floor. Maybe not this time- I was going with my dad who is probably too old for that-but some other time Id love to. While I was waiting in line for my tickets someone asked me where Id be seated. His actual words were "did they put you up top"? I told him yeah, that I was pretty far back. He said that was too bad and he thought it would have been pretty badass if I was on the floor. I know he was just kidding, but I agreed, and started thinking about it. I didnt see why I couldnt be. Sure, maybe being dead in the middle wouldnt be a good idea but being against the rail shouldnt cause a problem. Like you, Im not worried about my own safety; if I did get injured so what, it would be worth it. As for everyone else, they should watch the fuck out. Its not like I'll be moving all over.
Im glad that you didnt back down from the asshole staff. Its cool that Trent saw you. I'll admit it, Im jealous. That sounds like the experience of a lifetime. You've definitely inspired me. Maybe next time I see NIN I'll have as much balls as you.
The two men upstairs did not want me down there. They made it very clear. But the other event staff people had no problem with it as I passed them on my way down. Don't forget, I asked to sign a waiver too.
It was incredible!
The Only effect amazes me every single time. It's magical.
We are a rare breed. heh.
Over 100 shows and dozens of venues and only ONE of them has a decent handicapped section... the Electric Factory in Philly.
The only problem the rail causes for me is the knee crush since I do not have leg rests. That is a risk I'm willing to take though.
It never hurts to try!
I was one of the two guys standing directly behind the three of you.
Oh I'm aware that they were not all assholes. It seemed like the people who were on the Presale line and the GA line early (a.k.a. the people who started the concert in the first few rows.) were really nice people. It really was just spoiled by that group of guys. I'm sure you'll be glad to know I saw at least one of them get punched in the face. That made me smile.
Oh I know. It really just makes me wonder how they pull that kind of effect off. If you want to relive only, my sister caught video of that and a couple other songs. Right now they're hosted on my youtube, but tomorrow I'll be uploading them to my vimeo.
Awesome video. I have Only recorded from the East Rutherford show... somewhere. All I know is that the screen and Trent are not choreographed. He must have so much fun playing with that every show.
were you able to see over the barrier? i was at the show but not up the front, so i don't know how high it was, but all the wheelchair people i've seen have eye level lower than all the barriers i've seen, so i'm curious as to what your view was like.
I'm one of those under 5fters, and I agree a lot of people underestimate what we can stand! So long as you were within venue regulations, I'd be fine with you being down there - instinctually a little more cautious, because there's more metal and spokes etc for me to bang into - but you have a right to be there if the venue doesn't mind.
I caught this through the ETS forums and i read what other people said. Total bullshit.
It was pretty funny how Vic asked Nick and I if we were "good protectors."
Nick was pretty beat up from being in San Jose for a week and enduring many layovers just to get back midnight thursday and have my stupid ass call him like "DOOOOD, ARE YOU FECKIN READY?!?!"
"no, but come get me. let's do this."
With the power of 1,000 people pressing into me I more or less crushed your neice between myself and your wheelchair. I was thinking to myself most of the time, "...doesnt this defeat the purpose?"
I tried. I never talked to you personally, but you seemed like good peoples.
I'm glad amongst all of the stupid on-goings that are usual in pits, you got into it.
Cheers, babe.
You and Nick were lumped into the "Not everyone was an asshole" comment of mine. I seriously, majorly appreciated the two of you back there. Before I knew it, we were out of there and I didn't get to thank you.
So... thank you.
anytiiiiime
Basically, I was the other guy in back of you, along with Jeff. We tried to protect you to the best of our knowledge, but before we knew it, we were separated from you by a few songs in. However, we tried disparately to protect you. We tried.
I really respect you for your confidence and resilience. Stay strong.
-nick
Both of you helped me obtain an indescribable moment of my life. "Thank you" will never seem like enough.